Reducing employer national insurance contributions (NICs) for workers under 25 risks shifting unemployment onto older workers rather than cutting it, according to audit, tax and business advisory firm Blick Rothenberg, ahead of the publication of the Milburn report tomorrow.
Elisa Sofocli, a partner at the firm, said the proposal, which she described as reportedly included in the report due on 17 November, may not create jobs given how few vacancies are available.
“Given the limited number of jobs that are available, there is a risk that gradually reducing the NIC paid on under 25s, as reportedly proposed in the Milburn report, due to be published 17th November, shifts the joblessness problem along to older workers rather than actually decreasing unemployment,” she said.
Sofocli said the cost of employing staff had risen over the past decade for reasons beyond national insurance.
“The wider costs of employment have risen sharply over the last 5-10 years because of the increase in the minimum wage and increasingly heavy labour law obligations on employers, not just the rise in NICs. This has reduced the number of vacancies as employers struggle to justify the cost of more workers,” she said.
Under current HMRC rates and thresholds for employers, employers pay 15 per cent on earnings above £5,000 a year. Staff under 21 and apprentices under 25 are already exempt from employer contributions on earnings up to £50,270 a year Other employees aged 21 to 24 are charged at the standard rate.
Figures from UHY Hacker Young, reported by Business Matters in April, showed that employers’ national insurance bill rose from £116bn to £143.9bn in the year to 31 March 2026, following the increase in the main employer rate from 13.8 per cent to 15 per cent in April 2025.
Sofocli said there were still grounds for an incentive aimed at younger workers.
“However, given there are nearly one million young people not in education, employment or training, incentivising businesses to hire younger workers is still a positive step in the right direction. Many young people gain their first experience in sectors such as hospitality and retail who have been hit particularly hard by rising employment costs,” she said.
She said a tax cut would need to sit alongside wider measures. “However, this proposal will only be successful in expanding the workforce if it is also combined with the right investment in skills, training and employment support,” she said.
“Young people are entering a labour market being reshaped by AI and automation but this also impacts workers of all ages where jobs are potentially being displaced. A NIC reduction is putting a sticking plaster over the bigger issue we have, the jobs market has not adapted and pivoted to start building the right skills we need for the future.”
Skills have featured in earlier work for the review. Research carried out for Alan Milburn’s review found that 41 per cent of 500 businesses surveyed named weak soft skills and work readiness as the main barrier to hiring young people.
Sofocli said the risk of older workers being displaced by cheaper younger recruits needed to be considered. “Consideration therefore needs to be given for unintended consequences where older workers could then be competing with younger employees who are cheaper to hire. Hence the requirement for any NIC relief to be part of broader strategy that supports job creation,” she said.
She also questioned whether the relief would create additional roles. “Another critical question is whether a NIC reduction would genuinely create new opportunities for young people or simply lower the costs for jobs that would have existed anyway,” she said.
The Resolution Foundation raised a similar point in June, when it estimated that scrapping employer NICs for under-25s would cost £5.1bn and create 38,000 additional jobs for young people, equivalent to £132,000 for each extra job.
On the public finances, Sofocli said: “The NIC reduction will likely lead to lower tax revenues in the short term, but viewed longer term and the bigger prize is getting more young people into work, which turn may help broaden the tax base and reduce welfare costs over time.”












